Nine items make a photocatalysis dataset reproducible: catalyst mass (mg) and loading (mg/mL), reactor volume (mL), irradiated area (cm2), irradiance (mW/cm2 at a named band), temperature (°C) with its control method, pressure or flow, product calibration (R2 ≥0.999, stated LOD), and n ≥3 runs with standard deviation. Add a dark control and a mass balance within ±5 %.
A rate reported as “µmol h-1” is not a result until the reader can convert it to a per-gram, per-area or per-photon basis, and that conversion needs the denominators. Most failed reproductions are not wrong chemistry; they are missing denominators. The table below is the minimum set, and the fourth column is what actually goes wrong when the field is absent.
| Item | Unit | Report as | What fails without it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Catalyst mass | mg | 50.0 ±0.1 mg, weighed after drying at 105 °C | Rate per gram cannot be recomputed |
| Loading | mg/mL or g/L | 0.5 g/L in 100 mL | Light penetration and slurry opacity are unknown |
| Reactor volume | mL, with headspace | 100 mL total, 10 mL headspace | Gas-phase product concentration is unverifiable |
| Irradiated area | cm2 | 19.6 cm2 (50 mm circle) | Irradiance and photon flux cannot be derived |
| Irradiance | mW/cm2 | 100 ±10 mW/cm2 at 365 ±10 nm, at the window | No photon budget; AQY not checkable |
| Temperature | °C | 25 ±1 °C, water jacket, logged | Thermal contribution to rate is unknown |
| Pressure or flow | kPa, mL/min | 101 kPa batch; or 20 mL/min at ±1 % FS | Residence time and STY cannot be compared |
| Product calibration | R2, LOD | 5-point curve, R2 = 0.9995, LOD 20 ppm | Peak areas are not concentrations |
| Replicates | n, SD | n = 3, ±1 SD, fresh catalyst each run | Differences below 10 % are noise |
Two fields are usually omitted and both matter: catalyst pretreatment (purged, irradiated, or neither) and lamp hours at the time of measurement. A bulb with 600 h on it delivers 20–30 % less than the same model when new, which is enough to explain a seasonal drift in a lab's productivity figures.
“300 W xenon lamp, 20 cm from the reactor” appears in hundreds of papers and specifies nothing measurable. The lamp's electrical power is not the optical power, the distance is to a housing rather than to the liquid, and the window is not in the path during the measurement. Report instead: x mW/cm2 over a stated band, measured at the inner window face with the window and the reactor filled, using a meter whose calibration date and certificate number you can quote.
State the geometry with it, because a 50 mm spot at 100 mW/cm2 is 1.96 W of incident optical power, and the same lamp over 100 mm gives 400 mW/cm2 only if the optics allow it. A nine-point grid with the maximum deviation from the mean is the cheapest credibility you can add: a bare arc typically shows a 20–30 % centre hot spot, and a reader who assumes ±5 % will compute a photon flux you never delivered.
Apparent quantum yield is the ratio of reacted electrons to incident photons, so it carries two numbers that must be stated: the wavelength band that defines “photons”, and the electron count per product molecule. Hydrogen takes 2 electrons, CO takes 2, methanol 6, methane 8. Write the equation with both, plus how the photon flux was obtained — a calibrated radiometer or ferrioxalate actinometry — because the two agree only to about 10–15 % and a reader cannot tell which you used from a percentage alone.
Keep the conversion low when quoting AQY. Above roughly 10 % conversion the product accumulates, back-reaction and light screening flatten the rate, and the number is no longer a property of the catalyst. Faradaic efficiency for PEC work needs the same discipline: charge passed, product moles, and the cell configuration that produced them.
Put the numbers in this sequence and the methods paragraph writes itself: catalyst and loading, reactor and volume, light source and irradiance at the plane, temperature and pressure, analytical method with calibration and LOD, number of runs, then the derived metric with its equation. Anything that changes between runs — lamp hours, a new bulb, a rebuilt seal — belongs in a dated log referenced from the methods, not in a footnote added after review.
Both, for different purposes. Irradiance at the window plane, in mW/cm2 over a named band, is what enters the rate law and the photon budget. Lamp power and model identify the hardware and let a reader predict bulb ageing, but on their own they specify nothing.
Three independent runs with fresh catalyst, reported as mean ±1 standard deviation. Two is not enough to estimate scatter, and five rarely changes the conclusion while doubling the analysis load. If the effect you claim is smaller than the standard deviation, the honest report says so.
Below 10 %, and preferably in the 1–5 % band. Differential conditions keep product concentration low and light screening constant, so the quantum yield describes the catalyst rather than the extent of reaction.
Yes, and it is easier there. Close carbon or hydrogen to within ±5 %, and report the balance rather than a conversion alone — a high conversion with a 40 % unaccounted fraction usually means adsorption on the catalyst or a leak in the loop.